Both do the same job in the joint. Closed cell suits joints exposed to water, oils or solvents. Open cell is chosen for its compression and recovery and to avoid sealant bubbling.
KM closed cell polyethylene backer rod compared with KM open cell polyurethane backer rod
| Closed cell polyethylene (PE) | Open cell polyurethane (PU) |
| Material | Closed cell, low-density polyethylene foam with a skin-like outer texture. White or grey. | Open cell, medium-density polyurethane foam. |
| Key strength | Non-absorbent and chemically inert. Resists oils, solvents and water, and does not stain or adhere to sealant. | Excellent compression and recovery. Prevents sealant bubbling and gives a bond breaker behind the sealant. |
| Density | ≈ 28 kg/m³ (round rod); 30 kg/m³ (square foam, ISO 845) | 27 kg/m³ (nominal) |
| Temperature | -40 to +90 °C operating (square foam) | -40 to +70 °C service |
| Strength | Tensile > 0.22 MPa longitudinal, > 0.18 MPa transversal; elongation at break > 150% / > 180% (ISO 1798) | Tensile 85 kPa; tear resistance 250 N/m; resilience 40% |
| Compression | > 9 / > 27 / > 78 kPa at 10 / 25 / 50% deflection (ISO 3386); set < 10% after 24 h (ISO 1856) | Compresses readily and recovers; see data sheet |
| Sizes | Wide range of diameters. Ask for your joint width. | Multiple diameters. Ask for your joint width. |
| Best when | Joints may be wet or in contact with oils and solvents. | Compression and recovery matter and bubbling must be avoided. |
Typical values from the KM Closed Cell Polyethylene Square Backer Foam TDS (rev. 08.25) and the KM Open Cell Polyurethane Backer Rod TDS. Round PE rod density as listed for the product. Confirm figures against the current data sheet for your project.